Saturday, December 6, 2008

" LET'S LEARN FROM ISRAEL "- MUMBAI TERROR ATTACK

The way terrorists have once again been successful in inflicting tyranny of terror at the heart of India's financial capital-Mumbai on November 26 onwards for over more than 60 hours, with impunity has once again shows the moribund state of our intelligence networks that fails again and again in predicting such premeditated terror attacks, yes once again and three cheers for it!! These phrases of "once again" as either prefix or suffix have become an endless affair.

After every such terror attacks also comes volleys of condemnations, sympathy, calling for maintaining communal harmony and above all once again trumpeting the resilience of Mumbaikars and then happily going to their respective safe cocoons for a deep slumber till another spate of terror attacks rocks some other parts of India. This lame duck UPA Government suffers from a strange Chamberlainian paradox whose appeasement policy towards Hitler's Nazi Germany was severely criticized by Churchill thus, "The Government cannot make up their minds and go on in strange paradox, and so they decide only to be undecided, resolve only to be irresolute, are adamant for drift, solid for fluidity, all-powerful only to be impotent!" This has become an unbreakable vicious cycle. Once again the talk of having a Federal Investigating Agency and talk of strengthening intelligence agencies will do the rounds and the terror stricken nation will have another "100 days of finishing terrorism" as lollypop while the Government will sing all those rhetorical tones as sweet lullaby to put the Nation to sleep. Nation must sleep; otherwise another common man will rise to take law into his or her hand to eliminate these terrorists as he or she-I or you will naturally do when dirty cockroaches sneak into our kitchens. Terrorists and their terrorism have become like these endless breed of cockroaches, challenging our freedom in our kitchens as these mindless armed breeds do, challenging the might of the Indian State . They, the anonymous terrorists, are relishing their joy of reducing the omnipotence of the Indian State into sheer impotence, once again , by now. What are we waiting for or are we waiting for a "Wednesday" (as syndrome) to descend upon from reel life to real life with thousands of still potent aam admis armed with hit sprays to finish these bloody cockroaches once for all-for their security's sake, for the sake of freedom of their families, children's et al will hit the streets across India. Anarchy will engulf India , because if the Government blinded by its political expediencies fails to protect its citizens, then citizens-the aam janta will decide to protect themselves and the State will be compelled to show the same knee-jerk reaction to it as it has been doing so since time immemorial in fighting terrorism-the enemy of our freedom.


Let's learn from Israel , how they have managed to not just survive but flourished even with inheriting a rocky barren terrain as homeland and at the top of it being surrounded by hostile neighbours who pose as existential threat to this tiny Jewish Nation. They can, because they know how to deal with scores of enemies of Israel across the world. Their formula is simple- not an eye for an eye but both eyes for losing one eye, not tooth for tooth but the whole jaw for it. Israeli counter-terrorism responses have always created its desired results, which is to terrorize the very terrorists. Instead of the bloody hordes of terrorists, it is the Israeli retaliation that let loose a reign of terror in the hearts and minds of the terrorists. The terrorists, no matter how strong they are, always get the right message from Israel- "Don't mess with the Jews". The way they manage their borders and internal security is highly commendable and one can write a hundreds of pages, if not books or articles, on it. Every Jew is proud of their Nation, because they know like them it also cares about its brave citizens, not through tough talk but through tough action and that's why it invites awe, not pity, from others-even from its staunchest critics. In this hour of crisis, just one single statement from David Ben Gurion, Founding Father and first PM of Israel can act magic in raising the morale of all the nationalistic Indians of this great Nation soar high. He said to Ariel Sharon, former Defence Minister and later PM of Israel just before his death which has gone on records as the greatest Jewish anecdote ever- "Let me first tell you one thing: it doesn't matter what the world says about Israel, it doesn't matter what they say about us anywhere else. The only thing that matters is that we can exist here on the land of our forefathers. And unless we show the Arabs that there is a high price to pay for murdering Jews, we won't survive." The message for all of patriotic Indian citizens and its Government, irrespective of its political colour, is clear- mere words as platitudes won't do; only tough actions will do the talking. If we still fail to act, in spite of these entire bloodbaths as our own 9/11, we are heading for becoming another failed state worst than even cancerous Pakistan , i.e. Somalia , for sure. Posterity will, then, surely mark all of us as impotent Indians of a sterile Nation- India . That will be our worst nightmare becoming reality. Let's show the world that the potency of this 1billion plus great Nation can never be relegated to a pitiable dysfunctional impotency because the almighty Indian State will remain omnipotent. Its writ will ultimately prevail as good over evil, always as ever.

Article by Vineet Chaturvedi

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Mr. Kundra,

Are you really advocating that we go to war with Pakistan in order to revenge Mumbai? Israel did as much in the Lebanon. Has the problem with the Lebanese, Hezbollah, Syrians been controlled? Is it a case of the cure being worse than the disease? I have been to Israel and seen their situation at first hand. They clamour for an end to the daily madness they live in but find no way out. Israel is a Nation besieged.
Why don't we follow a more pragmatic path, again attributable to the Israelis and Americans? Why don't we put our own house in order by strengthening out anti terror apparatus? They have done so, specially the Americans. For 8 years now, 9/11 has not visited them.
Shifting the goal posts to Pakistan by punitive strikes will not end terror. Ask USA whether shifting the goal posts to Iraq and Afghanistan has helped them. We need to make ourselves terror proof by energetic and urgent action and organization.

Gen Raj Mehta

December 7, 2008 at 8:41 AM  
Blogger vaneet kundra said...

Dear Gen. Mehta,

Thanks for your comments. You have been at the helm of affairs and been to Israel also. You are in a much better position to answer, how we can combat terrorism, being in the army and also familiar about Israel. Sir, May i request you to give some concrete suggestions how can we strengthen our anti-terror mechanism, knowing very well, that these politicians will never allow anti-terror system to be out of their hands ? police and anti-terror mechanism needs to be totally independent, without any political interference, totally autonomous. Do you think our politicians will allow this to happen ? Since they want their hands in every pie !

December 7, 2008 at 8:55 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

it wasnice to see ur blog and the article
i think each 1 of us to wake up to support ant shield our MOTHER INDIA/
its high time now we cannot wait and watch our nation to b torn like this

VANDEY MATRAM

December 8, 2008 at 8:15 PM  
Blogger Ketan Shah said...

//We need to make ourselves terror proof by energetic and urgent action and organization.//

This is not a practical option till the Pakis keep preparing for terror in India and their local stooges in India keep helping them.

August 21, 2009 at 11:15 AM  
Blogger vaneet kundra said...

Ketan,
Till the sleeper cells are recognised and eliminated, Pak sponspored terror will keep on happening.. Pakistan and ISI have lot of logistic support in our country.. These people have to be eliminated but i dont hv any hope from Dhimmis like Congress. They are its appeasement vote banks..

August 21, 2009 at 11:55 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home